Title: A Magical New York Christmas

Author: Anita Hughes

Publisher: St. Martin’s Griffin 2021

Genre: Holiday Romance

Pages: 304

Rating: 3/5 stars

Reading Challenges: 

It’s Christmas week when 26-year-old Sabrina Post knocks on the door of the Vanderbilt suite at the Plaza Hotel in New York City, ready to accept the ghostwriting position for the memoir of Grayson Westcott—a famous art dealer.

A struggling journalist, Sabrina can't believe her luck: a paycheck and six nights in her own suite at the Plaza. She feels like Eloise, the heroine from her favorite children’s books. To make the job even more exciting, Grayson recounts how he worked as a butler at the Plaza sixty years ago for none other than the author of the Eloise books, Kay Thompson.

What promises to be a perfect week is complicated when Sabrina meets Ian Wentworth, a handsome British visitor, at the hotel bar. When Ian assumes Sabrina is another wealthy guest at the hotel, she doesn’t correct him —a decision she doesn’t regret after learning that Ian is a member of the British aristocracy. But, things are not what they seem. The truth is: Ian is not a wealthy lord; he’s actually the personal secretary of Lord Spencer Braxton.

As the week unfolds, will Sabrina and Ian learn the truth about one another.

Started out strong, but then became incredibly repetitive and pretty boring. I don’t think I really enjoy the mistaken identity trope; too much lying and evasion. And this one really kept that up until way too late in the book. And then we get to the weird underlying story of Kay and Grayson. I just didn’t really care and I was annoyed by how many times that we were reminded just how unusual Kay was. Boring. Spencer also did not really add to the plot at all. And then we get to Sabrina and Ian. I just didn’t see them enough together to get a sense of the romance. Every scene involving both of them was too brief. We just didn’t get enough. Too many flashbacks, not enough in the moment romance.

Next up on the TBR pile: